Primally Pure Everything Balm Review: Is the Tallow Balm Worth It?

We test and research the products we recommend. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Short answer: Primally Pure’s Everything Balm is a well-made, multi-ingredient tallow balm (grass-fed tallow, olive oil, emu oil, beeswax, calendula, marshmallow root, lavender and tea tree essential oils) sold in 1 oz and 2 oz jars from the brand’s own website. It works well as a rich, all-purpose balm, but it costs much more per ounce than comparable tallow balms, and the lavender and tea tree essential oils make it a poorer fit for very reactive skin. If you want the Primally Pure experience, buy it direct; if you want a similar balm for less, Vanman’s or Terra Lotus on Amazon come close.

---

Quick Verdict

Primally Pure’s Everything Balm is a genuinely well-made tallow product with quality ingredients, elegant packaging, and a formula that works. But you pay a steep premium per ounce, and part of that premium is branding and aesthetic. The tallow in the jar isn’t meaningfully better at moisturizing than what you’ll find from brands charging half as much. If budget isn’t a concern and you like the brand, Primally Pure delivers. If you care about what the product does on your skin more than how the jar looks on your shelf, there are better values.

Buy direct: Primally Pure Everything Balm at primallypure.com

---

What Is Primally Pure?

Primally Pure was founded by Bethany McDaniel, who made her first sale at a summer farm stand in 2014. Her family runs Primal Pastures, a regenerative livestock farm in Southern California, and the brand grew out of turning farm ingredients like tallow into skincare. It has since become one of the most recognizable names in natural skincare, with a following built largely through Instagram and clean-beauty influencers.

The brand says every product is made in-house in Temecula, California, rather than by a contract manufacturer. That’s worth noting because it means they control their process end to end.

The product line now goes well beyond tallow: cleansers, deodorant, lip products, body care, and tallow-based mineral sunscreens. But tallow balms and creams remain the core of the brand.

---

Primally Pure’s Tallow Lineup: Which Balm Is Which?

“Primally Pure tallow balm” can mean several products. Here are the tallow-based face and body balms the brand sells, per its product pages:

For most people searching “Primally Pure beef tallow,” the Everything Balm is the flagship and the one to start with. If you have reactive skin or dislike essential oils, the Baby Balm is the better Primally Pure choice because it drops the lavender and tea tree.

---

The Everything Balm: What You’re Getting

Full ingredient list (per Primally Pure): Organic tallow from grass-fed cows, organic olive oil, emu oil, unrefined beeswax, essential oils of organic lavender and organic tea tree, organic marshmallow root, organic calendula flower, organic rosemary extract, non-GMO vitamin E.

• Sizes: 1 oz and 2 oz
• Packaging: Glass jar with metal lid
• Directions (brand): massage a light layer onto skin after a mist or serum, or use it on its own on face or body

This is a longer ingredient list than most tallow balms. Tallow, olive oil, and beeswax do most of the work. Emu oil is another animal fat used as an emollient. Calendula and marshmallow root are traditional soothing botanicals, and rosemary extract and vitamin E help slow rancidity. There are no synthetic preservatives or fragrance compounds.

Two ingredients deserve a note for sensitive skin: tea tree oil and lavender oil are among the essential oils most often linked to allergic contact dermatitis, especially when they oxidize over time. Most people use them without trouble, but if you’ve reacted to essential oils before, choose the unscented Baby Balm or a plain unscented balm instead.

---

My Testing Experience

I used the Everything Balm daily for four weeks, alternating between face and body application. I also compared it directly with three other tallow balms I had on hand to benchmark performance.

Texture and Application

The texture is dense but smooth. It’s not whipped: this is a traditional balm consistency. You scoop a small amount with your finger, warm it between your palms, and press it into skin. The beeswax gives it more structure than pure tallow balms, which means it holds its shape in the jar even in warm weather.

Absorption takes 8-12 minutes on my skin, which is slower than whipped alternatives but typical for beeswax-containing balms. The beeswax creates a protective barrier that locks moisture in longer, which is the trade-off for the slower absorption.

The lavender scent is refined, softened by the tea tree, and fades within about 20 minutes.

Moisturizing Performance

The moisturizing performance is very good, but it’s not noticeably better than balms costing half as much.

After four weeks, my skin felt consistently hydrated. Dry patches on my hands and elbows resolved. The balm performed well as a nighttime face moisturizer, and I woke up with soft, non-greasy skin each morning.

But I got nearly identical results from Amallow’s unscented whipped tallow, which costs significantly less per ounce. And Vanman’s tallow balm delivered comparable moisturizing at a lower price point too. The tallow is doing the heavy lifting in all these products, and grass-fed tallow from one quality source performs much the same as grass-fed tallow from another.

The Beeswax Factor

Beeswax creates an occlusive layer, a physical barrier that slows moisture loss from your skin. That makes the Everything Balm a better choice for:

• Harsh weather protection (cold, wind, dry air)
• Overnight moisture sealing
• Cracked, very dry skin (hands, heels, elbows)

If you live in a humid climate and just want lightweight daily moisture, the beeswax layer might feel unnecessary. A whipped tallow will absorb faster and feel lighter. Our whipped beef tallow guide explains the difference.

---

What Primally Pure Gets Right

Ingredient integrity. Every ingredient is listed on the product page, the tallow comes from grass-fed cattle tied to the founder’s family farm, and there are no fillers.

Packaging and presentation. The glass jar, the labeling, the unboxing: it’s all polished. It looks good on a vanity and makes an easy gift.

A real lineup. Unlike single-product brands, Primally Pure has a tallow balm for most needs, including an unscented Baby Balm and tallow-based mineral sunscreens.

Brand transparency. Primally Pure publishes information about its farm, its manufacturing, and its ingredient philosophy, and explains why grass-fed sourcing matters.

---

What Gives Me Pause

The Price Premium Is Hard to Justify

Per ounce, Primally Pure costs several times more than comparable grass-fed tallow balms. Tallow, olive oil, beeswax, and essential oils are not expensive raw materials. You’re paying for the brand, the in-house production, the packaging, and the marketing. Check current prices before you decide, since the gap changes with sales and bundles.

The Jars Are Small

With 1 oz and 2 oz options, you’ll go through a jar quickly if you use it on both face and body. That can push the monthly cost into luxury skincare territory.

Influencer Amplification

Primally Pure’s growth has been heavily driven by wellness influencers. That doesn’t make the product bad, but it means much of the online enthusiasm is amplified by marketing. The product is genuinely good; it is not the transformative miracle some posts suggest.

---

Who Should Buy Primally Pure

Buy it if:

• Budget isn’t a primary concern for skincare
• You value premium packaging and a brand tied to a working farm
• You want a beeswax-containing formula for heavy-duty moisture
• You like lavender and tea tree scents
• You’re buying a gift

Skip it if:

• You want the best value per ounce
• You react to essential oils (choose the Baby Balm or an unscented balm)
• You prefer whipped, lightweight textures
• You want to buy on Amazon with fast shipping

---

Primally Pure Alternatives on Amazon

Primally Pure isn’t sold on Amazon. If you want a similar balm that is, these are the closest matches:

Vanman’s Tallow and Honey Balm: the closest formula. Like the Everything Balm, it’s built on tallow, beeswax, and olive oil, and it adds raw honey instead of emu oil and botanicals. Available with no added scent, and in a 6.3 oz jumbo jar that brings the per-ounce cost down a lot. Our Vanman’s review covers it in detail.

Terra Lotus Tallow Honey Balm: tallow, raw honey, and olive oil (the brand’s site also lists beeswax), a lavender version if you want Primally Pure’s scent profile, and 2 oz or 4 oz jars. See our Terra Lotus Tallow Honey Balm review.

Amallow Unscented Whipped Tallow: a different texture (whipped with sweet almond oil, no beeswax) in a 4 fl oz jar. Better for daytime face use; less occlusive than the Everything Balm.

Santa Cruz Paleo: tallow, beeswax, and honey only. The closest thing on Amazon to Primally Pure’s Baby Balm for adults who want no essential oils. It contains honey, so it isn’t a pick for babies under 12 months; Primally Pure’s Baby Balm has no honey.

Head-to-head comparisons: Primally Pure vs Amallow and Primally Pure vs Terra Lotus.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Primally Pure Everything Balm used for?

It’s an all-purpose tallow balm for face and body: a night cream, a treatment for dry patches on hands, elbows, and heels, and a barrier balm in cold weather. The brand also suggests using it after a mist or serum as part of a daily routine.

What is in Primally Pure Everything Balm?

Organic grass-fed tallow, organic olive oil, emu oil, unrefined beeswax, organic lavender and tea tree essential oils, organic marshmallow root, organic calendula flower, organic rosemary extract, and non-GMO vitamin E.

Is Primally Pure worth the money?

The product works well, but the performance doesn’t justify the per-ounce premium over comparable brands if moisture is all you care about. You’re paying for branding, packaging, in-house production, and a farm-to-jar story. If those things matter to you, it’s worth it.

Is Primally Pure tallow balm good for sensitive skin?

The Everything Balm contains lavender and tea tree essential oils, which some sensitive skin reacts to. Primally Pure’s Baby Balm is the unscented option. Our best tallow balm for sensitive skin guide lists other fragrance-free choices.

How does Primally Pure compare to homemade tallow balm?

If you’re willing to render your own tallow and make balms at home, you can make a tallow, olive oil, and beeswax balm for a fraction of the cost. The trade-off is your time and the learning curve.

Why doesn’t Primally Pure sell on Amazon?

Primally Pure sells through its own website and select retail partners. The direct-to-consumer model lets it control pricing and presentation, which is part of how it keeps its premium positioning.

---

Bottom Line

Primally Pure makes a legitimately good tallow balm. The ingredients are listed in full, the tallow comes from a farm tied to the founder’s family, and the product works. I have no complaints about what’s in the jar.

My complaint is what it costs to get that jar. The Everything Balm is priced like luxury skincare while delivering moisture that is functionally similar to balms costing much less per ounce. The premium buys you better packaging, a richer botanical blend, and the satisfaction of owning a brand you may already follow.

Rating: 3.8 out of 5. A well-made balm held back by its price per ounce, small jars, and essential oils that rule it out for some sensitive skin.

If that’s worth it to you, buy it from Primally Pure with confidence. If you’d rather put that money toward more product that works just as well, the Amazon alternatives above will serve you better.